Does ChatGPT Outshine Human Doctors in Empathy and Accuracy

The world of healthcare is witnessing a paradigm shift as artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots like ChatGPT demonstrate their prowess in providing accurate, empathetic, and comprehensive medical advice. Recent studies have shown that many people find these chatbots more caring and empathetic than their human counterparts. With ChatGPT outperforming human doctors in various aspects, we delve into the implications of this technological breakthrough and its potential impact on the future of healthcare.

Image Source : Exchange4media

ChatGPT vs. Human Doctors: A Comparative Study

A study published in JAMA Network compared the responses of ChatGPT and human doctors to health-related questions on the Reddit forum r/AskDocs. The results were astonishing, with ChatGPT providing better answers 78.6% of the time. The chatbot’s responses were also lengthier and more comprehensive, and it was deemed more empathetic nearly 10 times more often than human doctors.

ChatGPT’s Performance in Sensitive Areas

Another study analyzed ChatGPT’s responses to sensitive questions related to sexual and mental health, including queries about suicide. The results, published by JAMA, showed that ChatGPT provided evidence-based answers 91% of the time, significantly outperforming rivals like Amazon’s Alexa and Apple’s Siri. In most cases, the chatbot’s responses mirrored the type of support that might be given by a subject matter expert.

Room for Improvement: Referrals and Resource Recommendations

Despite its impressive performance, ChatGPT still has room for improvement. The chatbot provided referrals to specific resources, such as the National Suicide Prevention Hotline or Alcoholics Anonymous, only 22% of the time.

Study co-author Mike Hogarth emphasized the importance of connecting users with human experts through appropriate referrals, urging the leaders of emerging AI technologies to step up their efforts in this regard.

The Dark Side of AI Chatbots: A Cautionary Tale

While ChatGPT’s abilities are undeniably impressive, there have been instances where AI chatbots have caused harm. Earlier this year, a chatbot produced by Chai Research was blamed for encouraging a man to commit suicide.

Additionally, the creator of TV’s “Black Mirror” used ChatGPT to write an episode he described as “s – – t.” These incidents serve as a reminder that AI chatbots are not infallible and must be approached with caution.

The Future of Healthcare: Embracing AI with Caution

As AI chatbots like ChatGPT continue to make strides in healthcare, many doctors remain wary of giving them too much credit too soon. Dr. David Asch, senior vice dean at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perelman School of Medicine, expressed concerns about the “garbage-in, garbage-out” problem and the potential amplification of misinformation.

It is crucial to strike a balance between embracing the potential of AI chatbots and ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the information they provide. The rise of AI chatbots like ChatGPT in healthcare is a testament to the rapid advancements in artificial intelligence.

While these chatbots have demonstrated their ability to provide accurate, empathetic, and comprehensive medical advice, it is essential to approach their integration into healthcare with caution. By addressing the areas where they fall short and ensuring the accuracy of the information they provide, AI chatbots have the potential to revolutionize healthcare and improve the lives of countless individuals.


To work in a challenging environment that will test me at all levels and allow me to utilize and ameliorate my professional as well as personal skills by way of positive contribution to the organization while at the same time being resourceful, innovative and flexible.

Related Articles

Back to top button